Bartling v. Superior

Bartling v. Superior
Melissa Wells
Rasmussen College
Medical Law and Ethics

Bartling v. Superior
In this case, a mentally competent patient (Bartling) was military groupd to use a breathing device against his wishes. At the clock of his admission, Bartling was suffering from pulmonary emphysema, atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, coronary arteriosclerosis, an abdominal aneurysm and lung cancer. A needle biopsy of Mr. Bartlings left hand lung caused it to collapse. Attempts to inflate his lung failed and a mechanical ventilator was soon addicted by way of a tracheostomy. Mr. Bartling remained on the ventilator until the time of his death on November 6, 1984. He had some(prenominal) medical illnesses and did not want the ventilator despite knowing that it macrocosm aloof would speed his death. He repeatedly asked for it to be removed and when refused, he tried to remove it himself. He was then restrained to proscribe him from removing it. I believe the hospital had no even off to force him to have the ventilator. There was no chance of his reco actually and efforts to wean him from the machine were unsuccessful. I believe everyone should have a right to decide if they want to die. In my have case, I would never, low either circumstances, want to be forced to use a ventilator.



I believe if I cannot breathe under my own power, then I am not meant to live. In my opinion, being confined to bed and only staying alive by sentimental means is not living. Mr. Bartling had a living will subscribe stating that he understood that having the ventilator removed will very likely cause respiratory failure and ultimately expire to his death.and that he was willing to accept that risk. He also had several documents stating very clearly that he did not want to stick around living an artificial life finding it to be unbearable, debasing and dehumanizing. He, his wife and daughter also executed documents which released the hospital and its physicians from any claim of civil liability, should they honor Mr. Bartlings wishes....If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper